Although the pledge has been tampered with, or changed a few times, (along with the actual hand motions) — the message of NBC is that we don’t believe in God. And those of you who do, are silly.
For me, the pledge is really not that big of a thing, as a child, it had no meaning, a bunch of jumbled words, some that all ran together — forwhichitstands and invisble. The issue here is not so much tampering and editing, as it is the reason.
“I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one nation indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”
He wrote it to keep immigrants and native-born Americans, in-line, so they would not become subversive. But he seemed to want equality for all, even women, which was controversial then — and the paper did not want him to include the “equality and fraternity” bit.
There was a hand sign that went with the pledge, called the Bellamy salute. It looked exactly like the salute that Hitler later adopted — hand out-stretched, palm down. But at the end of the pledge, you would turn your palm up.
1941 Flag ceremony with salute:
This is an 1899 photo — not sure why their hands are not out-stretched — maybe the teacher did not like her students hitting the kid in front of them:
In 1923, the words, “the Flag of The United States” replaced “my flag” ( also to help immigrants remember to what they were pledging.) Then in 1942 “of America” was added.(more clarification)
In 1942, Franklin D. Roosevelt changed the hand signal to hand-over the heart. (It was looking too much like the Nazi salute.)
In 1954, another clergy, Pastor George MacPerson Docherty of the NY Presbyterian Church, held a little service at the church where Abraham Lincoln had attended. President Eisenhower was there. The pastor said our nation was set apart from others by being “under God.” (this in contrast to communist countries, such as Russia, which were atheist)